Milly's Market & Cafe

Finger Lakes Artisan Foods & Handmade Goods

Handmade gifts by local Finger Lakes artisans, crafts people and food vendors. Everything from one of a kind handwoven baskets, charcuterie boards, silk-knits, jewelry, photography, art and Keuka Lake souvenirs to locally made jams, pickles, sauces, dressings, salts, flours, organic foods and more. Biggest local food distributer on Main Street in Penn Yan! Check out our link here for more information on our artisan foods!

Market Café Menu

Home of the old-fashioned soda fountain! Classic and nostalgic old-fashioned sodas and cream sodas, phosphates, ice-cream floats, NY egg creams, milkshakes and now smoothies! Our Café drink bar is sure to bring a smile to your face. Our delicious homemade pies, pastries and cookies are also available for special catering orders. and specialty soda fountain and espresso drinks.

Building Rooms & Rentals

Nestled in a beautifully restored 19th century building on Main Street in Penn Yan is, what is now known as, Milly’s Market & Café. Located on the 1st, 2nd and 3rd floors of Milly’s Market & Cafe building are a collection of unique and functional rooms available for rent. 1st floor of the Market is a quaint little ‘Cafe’ space offered for private gatherings & meetings. On the 2nd floor, there is a commercial kitchen with attached dining area for those looking to expand their business in the food industry, educational cooking classes, etc. On the 3rd floor, our ‘gem’ of the building, is a magnificent ballroom for private parties and health and wellness class instruction.